What Route Does (and Where It Falls Short)
Route provides three core services for Shopify stores: shipping protection (package insurance against loss, theft, and damage), visual order tracking (branded tracking pages and notifications), and carbon-neutral shipping offsets. The platform adds a small insurance fee at checkout that customers can opt into, covering the cost of replacing lost or damaged packages. Route’s tracking feature provides customers with a visual, branded tracking experience instead of generic carrier tracking pages.
However, Route’s shipping protection model has faced criticism for its claims process, commission structure, and the questionable necessity of package insurance for most orders. Many merchants find that the conversion benefits of Route are overstated compared to more direct conversion optimization tools.
1. Questionable Value of Shipping Protection
Modern carriers (USPS, UPS, FedEx) already have claims processes for lost or damaged packages, and credit card companies offer purchase protection. Route adds a layer of insurance that duplicates existing protections, charging customers $1–$5 per order for coverage they may already have. This checkout upsell can create friction and customer skepticism rather than confidence.
2. Claims Process Complaints
Route has faced significant customer complaints about denied claims, slow resolution times, and difficult refund processes. A shipping protection service that frustrates customers when they need it most creates negative brand association for your store, even though Route handles the claims. Your customer blames your store, not Route, when their claim is denied.
3. No Direct Conversion Optimization
Route provides post-purchase services (protection and tracking) but does nothing to convert visitors into customers in the first place. It does not capture emails, suggest products, create urgency, or incentivize larger carts. The EasyApps suite addresses the entire pre-purchase conversion funnel where the biggest revenue opportunities exist, for a predictable monthly cost.
4. Commission-Based Revenue Model Misalignment
Route earns revenue from shipping protection premiums. This creates an incentive structure where Route benefits from higher premium adoption, which may not align with your customers’ best interests. EasyApps earns revenue from a simple monthly subscription, aligning incentives with your success: you pay the same whether you sell 10 or 10,000 orders.
EA Email Popup & Spin Wheel vs Route: Head-to-Head Feature Comparison
| Feature | EA Email Popup & Spin Wheel | Route |
|---|---|---|
| Free Plan | Yes — fully functional | Limited free trial |
| Paid Plans Start At | $9.99/mo | Revenue share on protection fees/mo |
| Revenue Impact | Direct conversion + email capture | Post-purchase protection revenue |
| Customer Journey Stage | Pre-purchase (entire funnel) | Post-purchase only |
| Email Capture | Gamified spin wheel — 8–15% opt-in | No |
| AOV Increase | Free shipping bar + upsells | No (checkout upsell only) |
| Setup Complexity | One-click install, 10-minute setup | Integration + configuration |
| Mobile Optimized | Fully responsive, lightweight | Mobile tracking app available |
| Branding Removal | No branding on any plan | Requires paid plan |
| Part of Larger Suite | Yes — 10-app conversion suite | No — standalone app |
| Annual Cost (Growing Store) | $0–$119.88 | Variable — commission-based |
Route vs EasyApps: Pricing Comparison
One of the biggest reasons merchants switch from Route is pricing. Here is how the costs compare across different store sizes and needs:
| Plan Tier | EasyApps Suite | Route |
|---|---|---|
| Free / Starter | $0/mo — full features, no limits | Free trial or limited free tier |
| Growing Store | $9.99/mo for premium features | Revenue share on protection fees/mo base plan |
| Established Store | $9.99–$19.99/mo for full suite | $50–$200+/mo for advanced features |
| Annual Savings | Save $200–$2,000+/year vs Route | — |
Why EA Email Popup & Spin Wheel Is a Better Route Alternative
1. Pre-Purchase vs. Post-Purchase Impact
The biggest revenue opportunities in ecommerce are in the pre-purchase phase: converting browsers into buyers, increasing cart values, and capturing emails from leaving visitors. EasyApps addresses all of these high-impact moments. Route only operates after the purchase is complete, providing services that do not influence the buying decision. Invest in tools that grow revenue (EasyApps) rather than tools that add post-purchase complexity (Route).
2. Predictable Costs vs. Variable Commissions
EasyApps has a simple, predictable cost: $0–$9.99/month regardless of order volume. Route’s commission-based model means your costs fluctuate unpredictably. As your store grows and more customers opt into shipping protection, Route’s take increases. With EasyApps, growth costs the same as starting out.
3. Build Your Own Tracking Experience
Rather than paying Route for branded tracking, use Shopify’s native order tracking and customize your order confirmation and shipping notification emails. Combine with the EasyApps suite for post-purchase email marketing through EA Spin Wheel’s email capture and your email platform’s automation. You build owned customer relationships instead of routing customers through Route’s tracking interface.
4. Eliminate Checkout Friction
Route’s shipping protection checkbox at checkout adds a decision point that can slow the purchase process. Any additional choice at checkout increases the risk of cart abandonment. EasyApps tools work before checkout to build purchase motivation and confidence, then EA Sticky Add to Cart streamlines the path to purchase. Fewer checkout complications means higher completion rates.
5. Part of a Complete Conversion Suite
This is where the EasyApps ecosystem decisively wins. Route is a standalone tool — it handles one category of functionality. EA Email Popup & Spin Wheel is part of the EasyApps suite of 10 Shopify apps that work together to optimize every stage of the conversion funnel. After implementing EA Email Popup & Spin Wheel, you can drive higher cart values with EA Free Shipping Bar, suggest complementary products with EA Upsell & Cross-Sell, create urgency with EA Countdown Timer, and reward larger orders with EA Auto Free Gift & Rewards Bar. Running the full suite costs less than Route alone.
The EasyApps Suite: A Complete Conversion Stack
Choosing EasyApps over Route means you are not limited to a single tool. The full EasyApps suite includes 10 specialized Shopify apps that work together:
- EA Email Popup & Spin Wheel: Gamified email and SMS capture with 8–15% opt-in rates
- EA Sticky Add to Cart: Always-visible add-to-cart bar that reduces purchase friction
- EA Upsell & Cross-Sell: Smart product recommendations to increase average order value
- EA Free Shipping Bar: Threshold-based shipping incentives with progress visualization
- EA Auto Free Gift & Rewards Bar: Automatic free gifts at cart value thresholds
- EA Announcement Bar: Promotional messaging and urgency banners
- EA Countdown Timer: Scarcity and urgency countdown elements
- EA Page Speed Booster: Performance optimization for faster load times
- EA Accessibility: ADA compliance and accessibility tools
- EA Auto Language Translate: Multi-language support for international stores
Running the entire EasyApps suite costs less than Route’s mid-tier plan alone — and covers dramatically more of your store’s conversion optimization needs.
How to Switch from Route to EasyApps (Step-by-Step)
Removing Route and replacing its value with more impactful tools is straightforward:
Step 1: Audit Your Current Route Setup
Review your Route data: what percentage of customers opt into protection, how many claims have been filed, and what is the total commission Route has earned from your store? Evaluate whether the protection adds genuine customer value or just checkout complexity.
Step 2: Install the EasyApps Suite
Install the EasyApps suite for pre-purchase conversion optimization: EA Spin Wheel for email capture, EA Free Shipping Bar for AOV incentives, and EA Upsell & Cross-Sell for product recommendations.
Step 3: Configure and Customize
Improve your own shipping and post-purchase experience: use quality carriers with tracking, set up branded order confirmation emails, and create post-purchase email sequences through your email platform (using emails captured by EA Spin Wheel).
Step 4: Test Before Going Live
Remove Route and monitor your checkout conversion rate. Many merchants see improved checkout completion when the shipping protection upsell is removed, as the simpler checkout reduces decision fatigue.
Step 5: Disable Route and Monitor
Track your overall conversion rate, email capture volume, and AOV with EasyApps active. The pre-purchase optimization from EasyApps typically delivers more revenue impact than Route’s post-purchase protection service.
Pro Tip: After switching, monitor your key metrics (conversion rate, average order value, email capture rate) for at least 7 days. Most merchants see equal or better performance because EasyApps’ lightweight code and mobile-first design captures more of the 60–70% of Shopify traffic coming from phones and tablets.
Who Should Still Use Route?
To be fair, Route may still be the right choice for certain merchants:
- Stores shipping fragile or high-value items: If you sell products with high loss/damage rates (glass, electronics, luxury goods), shipping protection provides genuine customer value and can reduce your own replacement costs.
- Stores with international shipping challenges: If you ship internationally to regions with unreliable postal services, package protection addresses a real customer concern that builds purchase confidence.
- Merchants who generate meaningful protection revenue: If Route’s protection fees generate significant additional revenue with minimal claims, the economics may justify keeping it as a profit center alongside EasyApps for conversion optimization.
For the majority of Shopify stores, however, EA Email Popup & Spin Wheel and the broader EasyApps suite deliver the same or better functionality at a significantly lower price point — with the added benefit of 9 additional conversion optimization apps included.
Replace Route with EasyApps — Free
Get EA Email Popup & Spin Wheel plus 9 more conversion optimization apps. Free plan, no branding, setup in under 15 minutes.
Browse All EasyApps →10 free Shopify apps. One conversion optimization suite.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Route shipping protection necessary for Shopify stores?
For most Shopify stores shipping standard products domestically, Route is unnecessary. Modern carriers have their own claims processes, and credit cards offer purchase protection. The shipping protection fee adds checkout friction without meaningfully improving conversion. Invest in EasyApps pre-purchase tools that drive more revenue than post-purchase protection.
What is better than Route for increasing Shopify revenue?
The EasyApps suite provides direct pre-purchase conversion optimization: gamified email popups (8–15% opt-in), free shipping bars (15–25% AOV increase), product upsells (10–20% AOV increase), and urgency timers. These tools address the biggest revenue opportunity (converting browsers into buyers) rather than Route’s post-purchase protection focus.
Does removing Route hurt Shopify conversion rates?
Most merchants report no decrease — and sometimes an increase — in checkout conversion after removing Route. The shipping protection checkbox adds a decision point that can slow checkout. A cleaner checkout with fewer upsells often converts better. EasyApps tools drive conversion before checkout, where the bigger opportunities exist.
How should I handle lost packages without Route?
File claims directly with the carrier (USPS, UPS, FedEx, DHL). For high-value items, purchase shipping insurance through your carrier. For occasional lost packages, replacing them directly builds stronger customer relationships than routing complaints through a third-party claims process. The cost of occasional replacements is typically less than Route’s ongoing commissions.
Can I replace Route tracking with a free alternative?
Yes. Shopify includes native order tracking, and apps like Shop (by Shopify) provide branded tracking experiences for free. Customize your shipping notification emails to include tracking links and post-purchase marketing. Combined with EA Spin Wheel email capture and your email platform, you create a better post-purchase experience than Route provides.