Why pet stores benefit from a rewards bar

Most of what a pet store sells runs out: dry food, wet food, treats, chews, litter, poop bags, flea and tick products. Shoppers often add the bag of food they are about to run out of and check out, leaving easy add-ons such as treats, a toy or poop bags behind.

A rewards bar gives that reason. It shows how far the shopper is from the next reward (free shipping, an amount or percentage off, or a free gift) with a line like "Add a little more for a free treat sample for your dog".

Pet stores have two extra reasons to use one:

One honest note before you start: a rewards bar rewards the order the shopper is building right now. It is not a points-based loyalty program. It can support repeat purchases, for example with codes that unlock a reward on the next order, but bringing customers back still depends on email, good service and the products themselves. Our guide to customer retention strategies covers the rest of that picture.

What to set up first

Make four decisions before you open the app.

1. Know your typical order. Open Shopify Analytics and look at your average order value and at a handful of recent orders. Your first reward goal should sit a little above that typical order, so most shoppers are already close when they open the cart. Our guide on how to increase average order value explains how to read these numbers.

2. Choose gift products that cost you little and ship easily. Good pet store gifts are small, light, useful for most pets and cheap for you to stock: a sample pouch of treats, a single dental chew, a small toy, a roll of poop bags, a bandana or a lick mat. Make sure each gift is an active product, in stock and available on your Online Store sales channel, otherwise it cannot be added to a cart.

3. Decide which products count toward rewards. The app lets only chosen products or collections count toward a reward, and gift cards never count. Leave out items with very thin margins, such as bulk bags you already price aggressively.

4. Check your existing shipping rates. If your store already gives free shipping above a certain cart value, build your tiers around that number instead of creating a second, different free shipping goal. Our guide to choosing a free shipping threshold can help you pick it.

Step-by-step setup

With those decisions made, the setup itself is short. Install EA Rewards Bar & Free Gifts from the Shopify App Store and work through these steps.

  1. Turn the app on in your theme. Follow the app's prompt to enable it in the theme editor so the bar can load on your storefront.
  2. Create your first tier. Set the goal a little above your typical order and pick the reward. For a pet store, free shipping or a small treat sample both work well as a first step because they are easy to understand.
  3. Add one or two more tiers. The app supports up to 6 tiers, but two or three is plenty to start. A common shape is free shipping first, then a free gift, then an amount or percentage off for the largest orders.
  4. Choose how gifts are given. Gifts can be added to the cart for the shopper when the goal is reached, or picked by the shopper from a gift picker. Either way, a gift is removed again if the cart drops below the goal.
  5. Choose where the bar shows. The bar can show at the top of the page, on product pages, in the cart drawer or on the cart page. The cart drawer and cart page matter most, because that is where shoppers decide whether to add one more item.
  6. Style it to match your store. Pick a card per reward, a gradient bar or a compact ring, and turn on confetti for the moment a reward unlocks.
  7. Write short, specific messages. Name the reward and the pet: "Add a bit more for a free chew for your dog" says more than "You are close to a reward".
  8. Test the whole journey. Add items until each goal is reached, check that the gift appears and is free, then remove items and check that it disappears. Go through to checkout and confirm the discounts apply there. Finally, try a cart that contains only the gift: the app's checkout rules stop orders that contain only free gifts.

Settings that suit pet stores

Use the gift picker when pets differ. A dog toy is useless to a cat owner. If your customers own different animals, let the shopper choose from two or three gifts (for example a dog chew, a cat treat pouch and a universal poop bag roll) rather than adding one gift for everyone.

Count items, not just cart value, for consumables. Tiers can be based on cart value or on item count. Item-count goals suit products bought in multiples, such as cans and pouches of wet food: "Add 2 more cans for a free treat" is easy to understand and nudges shoppers toward a fuller week of meals.

Give a gift with a specific product. The app can give a free gift with a specific product. Pair a food scoop or a storage clip with large bags of food, or a sample of a new treat with a best-selling food.

Use codes for the next order. The app can create codes that unlock a reward. Put one in your order confirmation or follow-up emails, or on a card in the parcel, so the customer has a reason to come back to you for the next bag of food.

Schedule seasonal rewards. Rewards can run on set dates, so you can plan a holiday gift, a summer offer on cooling mats and travel bowls, or a weekend promotion without remembering to switch it on and off.

Target countries and customers where it makes sense. Rewards can run in chosen countries or for chosen customers. If heavy gifts are expensive to ship abroad, keep gift tiers to the countries where you ship cheaply and offer a discount tier elsewhere.

What to test

Once the bar has run for a while, test one change at a time. The app includes A/B tests for reward amounts, which is the most useful place to start.

Let each test run for full weeks, so weekday and weekend shopping are both included, and wait until enough orders have come through before you pick a winner. Changing several things at once makes it impossible to know which change mattered.

What to measure

Decide what success looks like before you launch, then check the same numbers each week or month.

Compare periods of the same length and, where you can, the same season: holiday peaks say little about the bar itself.

Common mistakes

Frequently Asked Questions

Is EA Rewards Bar & Free Gifts free?

Yes. EA Rewards Bar & Free Gifts is 100% free with no view limits and no paid plans. You can install it from the Shopify App Store.

What free gifts work well for a pet store?

Small, light and low-cost items that most pets can use: a sample pouch of treats, a single dental chew, a small toy, a roll of poop bags or a bandana. If your customers own different animals, use the gift picker so each shopper can choose a gift that suits their pet.

How many reward tiers should a pet store start with?

Two or three. The app supports up to 6 tiers, but a short list is easier to read, especially on a phone. A common start is free shipping first, then a free gift, then an amount or percentage off for the largest orders.

Can shoppers check out with only the free gift?

No. The app's checkout rules stop orders that contain only free gifts, and a gift is removed from the cart if the cart drops below the goal.

Will a rewards bar bring pet owners back to my store?

A rewards bar rewards the order the shopper is building now; it is not a points-based loyalty program. It can support repeat purchases, for example with codes that unlock a reward on the next order, but bringing customers back also depends on your emails, service and products. Track your returning customer rate over several months to judge it.

Set Up Your First Reward Tiers

EA Rewards Bar & Free Gifts is 100% free with no view limits. Install it and set your first tiers in minutes.

Install EA Rewards Bar & Free Gifts

See every feature of EA Rewards Bar & Free Gifts